Tuesday

Third time a charm for theme park in Myrtle Beach?

Sun News - The owners of the former Freestyle Music Park continue to search for a buyer or new operator as experts wonder whether the third time might be a charm for the twice-failed theme park. Attorneys for FPI US, the mortgage holder who bought back the property for $7 million during a foreclosure auction in August, have been handing out proposal guidelines to potential buyers and park operators with the goal of reopening the park off U.S. 501 in Fantasy Harbour by the summer tourism season next year. To have time to get the park ready by next summer, a new owner or operators should come on board this fall, officials said. As the search for a new operator continues, economists and theme park experts disagree on whether the theme park can succeed in the Myrtle Beach area, where tourists flock to the beaches during the day – not a theme park. Still, some are still rooting for the park to take off and say it can work if done right, which would include major changes in the way the park operated during its first two summers in 2008 and 2009 – both of which ended in bankruptcy or foreclosure. “It’s a challenge, but there’s still potential,” said John Gerner, managing director for Leisure Business Advisors, a Richmond, Va.-based firm that does feasibility and design work for theme parks and other amusements. “People in my industry, we are cheering for that park to come back.”

‘Colossal failure …’ Some say the theme park’s ride in Myrtle Beach is over. Owners have tried twice to make the park work, and neither could. The $400 million attraction debuted as Hard Rock Park in 2008 but closed after one summer and was sold out of bankruptcy in February 2009 for $25 million. FPI MB reopened it as Freestyle Music Park in May 2009, but it failed again after the summer, falling into foreclosure owing money to bands, website designers and other firms that did business with the park – payments most of them never received. It will be difficult to find investors, not only because of today’s tough economy but because of the park’s track record, said Rob Salvino, an economist at Coastal Carolina University. When a company buys a $400 million park at the bargain of $25 million and still can’t make it work, it doesn’t seem promising, he said. “And it still didn’t make it,” Salvino said. “I don’t know how you could pay less for it. “I think it would be a very high-risk investment for a group to take on,” Salvino said, adding that he doesn’t think the park can succeed even if it did find investors. “When you look at that much of a colossal failure … the likelihood is just not very good [that it would succeed].”

Attorneys for FPI say they’ve gotten several groups interested in the park – though they declined to say how many – and that “most people are still very positive about Myrtle Beach,” said Franklin Daniels, an attorney representing FPI. Despite the park’s bumpy ride, FPI is confident the park can be successful here with the right operators, he said. “They completely believe it can work and want it to work,” Daniels said. “We are in a tough economy and the park has its history. … But there are enough tourists who come here who want to be entertained. It would be a fun and interesting thing to do while you’re at the beach.” Locals and experts have speculated about what went wrong with Hard Rock Park and Freestyle. Most blame its location several miles away from the beach, high ticket prices – especially during a recession when consumers aren’t opening their wallets – and the daytime competition from the amenity that brings tourists here to begin with: the beach. “The beach is a dynamic that really makes it hard for a theme park to do well,” Gerner said. “Generally, [tourists] are already there to do something else during the day.” About 14 million tourists visit the Grand Strand each year, most of them lured by the ocean or golf. A theme park will be an activity they do after the beach – such as a Broadway at the Beach experience – and will never be the main reason vacationers come here like Disney World is in Orlando, experts say. “Will it be a destination like Carowinds or Six Flags or Mickey Mouse? Not unless Six Flags comes in,” said Horry County Councilman Gary Loftus, whose district includes the theme park. “It’s not going to be a destination. It’ll be like Broadway [at the Beach] – something to do when they get here.”

‘Off the beaten path’ Loftus and others said the theme park could have a place here if it operated like the beachside amusement parks that have done well for so many years, including Family Kingdom Amusement Park and The Myrtle Beach Pavilion Amusement Park, which closed in 2006. A key to success is crafting a business plan that fills that niche, said Mark Lazarus, a veteran amusement park operator along the Grand Strand who contacted FPI’s attorneys to express interest in working with investors to make the former Freestyle work. Lazarus also tried to buy the park out of bankruptcy after its first season as Hard Rock Park. “I still think it has potential if it is done the right way,” Lazarus said. Dropping the gate fee is one of the first steps, he said. Lazarus and others said the ticket price – starting at $40 for adults as Freestyle – was way out of reach for budget-conscious families – especially during the spending cutbacks of the recession. And unlike Disney-goers, theme park visitors here don’t want to stay the whole day recouping that cost; they are more likely to see a trip to the theme park as a way to cap the day, experts said. Experts suggest free admission, with guests paying for what they want to do while inside, such as buying a wristband for rides or a ticket to a concert. Lazarus suggested opening in midafternoon and staying open until midnight, possibly with a laser light show as a nightly feature. “If the gate is free, a lot of people will just venture in,” Lazarus said.

The park’s location is another challenge, experts say. It’s about 5 miles from the oceanfront, so tourists have to make an effort to go west of the Intracoastal Waterway instead of just strolling along the main strip or driving a couple of miles to Broadway, they said. “This place is off the beaten path a little bit,” Salvino said.
The park also needs to be more easily seen by drivers along busy U.S. 501 headed into the beach – several experts suggested demolishing the mall building. In addition, the Fantasy Harbour area itself needs some sprucing up, experts said. More rides also would make the park more appealing and give guests more to do, Lazarus said.

A summer 2012 opening  - The park’s owners want to have the theme park ready to go for summer 2012. It has been closed for the past two summers as officials worked through its financial and legal woes, though a few workers stayed on to regularly run the rides and keep them in shape. They are gearing up even more now to possibly show off the park to potential buyers or operators, Daniels said. But some local leaders – even though they want to see the park reopen and be successful – aren’t sure a summer opening is in the cards. Loftus said the park can be successful with the right business plan, but said the new owners or operators should wait a couple of years until the economy has improved. “I think it could [succeed], I just don’t think the time is right,” Loftus said. “But I hate to see it just sitting there.” Theme parks across the country haven’t escaped the down economy. The industry improved some in 2010, but the verdict on the 2011 season is still out, said Colleen Mangone, a spokeswoman for the International Association of Amusement Parks and Attractions. Parks have reported mixed results, with some saying wet weather at the beginning of the 2011 season hurt attendance, while others said attendance, season pass sales and corporate outings to the parks continued to increase, she said. “We are still feeling the effects of the economy,” Gerner said. “There seems to be a feeling that things are improving. We are holding our own.” Experts said it’s too early to say how 2012 might shape up – a lot of it will depend on which way the economy goes in the next few months. Still, several parks – including Dollywood and Carowinds – are adding major, multimillion-dollar rides for 2012.

It’s unclear how long it would take to get the former Freestyle park ready to open by the summer. Freestyle owners did it in about three months, but Lazarus said it would take eight months to a year to get it ready through rebranding, marketing and adding rides. So if the park wants to open in 2012, a buyer or operator needs to be locked in soon, Lazarus said. “It needs to be happening right now,” he said. Now is a tough time to line up investors, especially considering the park’s history, Horry County Council Chairman Tom Rice said. Still, a reopened park could create much-needed jobs in Horry County, which like many other areas in the state and the country, is being hammered by double-digit unemployment rates, he said. “If I was an investor, I’d be cautious,” Rice said. “If somebody buys it, I wish them the best of luck. We sure need the jobs.” The Myrtle Beach Regional Economic Development Corp., the county-funded agency charged with luring jobs and businesses here, has talked with the park’s existing owners about state job tax credits that a new operator might qualify for, but it is not pursuing theme park operators because it is focusing on diversifying the tourism-based economy by luring aviation, marine and technology businesses, president Brad Lofton said. “I would hope somebody could make some good use of it,” Rice said.

Thursday

Freestyle Music Park bought out of foreclosure

Sun News - The theme park formerly known as Freestyle Music Park might be back in business in time for summer 2012.  FPI US LLC, the mortgage holder of the former park that has been closed for two years, bought the property out of foreclosure this week with a goal of reopening the theme park in Fantasy Harbour in time for next summer, its attorneys said Wednesday.  “There’s a little bit of light at the end of the tunnel,” said David Slough, an attorney for FPI US.  Elected leaders and business owners near the park heralded the news Wednesday, saying it could help rejuvenate an area that desperately needs it.  “Any time you can take something that is dead and you can bring some life to it, it is good,” said Horry County Councilman Gary Loftus, whose district includes the theme park area.  FPI US is looking for either a partner to manage and operate the park or a buyer who can purchase the park and reopen it, Slough said.  Talks are in the early stages, so it’s not clear exactly when the park would open, whether it would still be called Freestyle or whether it would create a new theme.  “They hope it reopens and it’s a big success,” said Franklin Daniels, an attorney for FPI US. “They don’t want to see it be a vacant theme park. They are not willing to just let it go.”

FPI US LLC, which had foreclosed on former park operators FPI MB Entertainment LLC a year ago, bought the property at the Horry County foreclosure auction Monday through a “credit bid” of $7 million. That means FPI US gets the property but doesn’t pay that amount because it’s already owed more than that by the former park operators. The total debt was $34 million, according to court records. Other businesses that were still owed money by Freestyle are out of luck.  FPI US won the auction over one other bidder, Alton Swann, a real estate professional in Myrtle Beach who said during a brief telephone conversation Wednesday that he had been working on a plan to bring somebody in to take over the park.  “I’d just like to see something happen to it,” he said. “It’s a shame to see it go to waste.”  The 50-acre theme park has sat idle for about two years, a far cry from the hoopla that marked its first and second openings during a two-year period.  The theme park, which was built for $400 million, originally was branded as Hard Rock Park and debuted in 2008. It filed for bankruptcy protection after a slow first season.

The park’s second run started early the following year when a group of investors bought it out of bankruptcy for $25 million in February 2009 and reopened it as Freestyle Music Park a few months later. It also fell into financial troubles after just one summer - a season where tourism statewide took a hit because of the lagging economy that kept many people from traveling or prompted them to cut back on their spending if they did go on vacation.  The park has been closed since, riding a wave of cases in court. With the litigation behind it, the park can move forward, Daniels said.  FPI plans to look at what went wrong the first two times the park operated, identify what needs to happen to make the park a success and find a buyer or good partner to manage the park, Daniels said.  That means the theme, marketing and ticket prices – which some critics said were too high, especially during the tough economy – all will be reviewed, he said. Tickets for admission to Freestyle started at about $40 for adults and about $30 for children, though the park dropped them later in the summer 2009 to less than $20 for special promotions.

“Many things in the past have to be done differently,” Daniels said. “They’ve learned a lot of hard lessons, lost a lot of money. But they are committed to it.”  Some business owners in the Fantasy Harbour area, off U.S. 501 at the Intracoastal Waterway, said a revived theme park could be the first step in getting the area back to where it should be. A re-opened theme park could bring more people to the area and make it look better, said Robbie Love, owner of The X Sports Center off George Bishop Parkway near the park.  "Definitely, that’s a boost,” he said. “That should be a good shot in the arm for the area.”  Having the park reopen might not translate into more business at the Clarion Hotel and Conference Center on Fantasy Harbour Boulevard, but it would help the look of the area, said Lori Posma, the hotel’s sales director.  “That would be great,” she said. “Just the perception of the area - everybody says it looks so decrepit over here...Any action over here would be fabulous.”  During the past two years, theme park operators and others have stopped by the park interested in buying some of the rides, but the investors didn’t want to sell off the park piece by piece, still optimistic that the theme park could eventually work in Myrtle Beach, Daniels said. A small crew has continued to work at the park, including an engineer who regularly runs the rides to keep them in shape, Daniels said.

“You start selling off the rides, you destroy the value of the theme park,” he said. “They truly are committed. They want to see it reopen. They want to see it work.”  But they’ve learned lessons from the park’s back-to-back failures, Daniels said.  Loftus said a theme park can work in the Myrtle Beach area if it’s done right.  "There were many issues that kind of led to the demise of the first two. Obviously, there were a heckuva lot more that went wrong than right,” Loftus said. “Done correctly, and with the right marketing, it should have a chance.”  One culprit that hampered the park’s second run was the Great Recession, which led to an 8 percent drop in tourism in South Carolina in 2009, according to figures released this week by the S.C. Parks, Recreation and Tourism department. Tourism throughout the state generated $14 billion in 2009, down about $1 billion from the previous year.  Tourism officials have said the industry has picked up since then.  FPI’s talks with potential managers or buyers are in the early stages, and it’s unclear when FPI would announce details of a reopening. It probably would take between six and nine months to adequately prepare the park and promote it, though Freestyle owners did it in three months after they bought the park out of bankruptcy.  “There’s no timeframe,” Daniels said. “They are working hard.”  Posma of the Clarion hotel, like Loftus, said a theme park could be successful here.  “If they take input they have learned and apply it, commit to it, I think they can make it work,” she said. “I’m hoping for the best.”